It's not too often when I make more than one journal, but, I'm irritated enough to feel compelled to write this. (Oh, and there's a completely random edit on the bottom of the page.)
Rant Warning: If you don't want to sit through a rant, then don't. Please note that this is, unsurprisingly, a Lupin-relevant rant, too. Also note that there will be a lot of drunken-esque redundancy here. Thoughts are scrambled.
Okay. Here is something I wrote earlier on the subject of fanfiction.
"Let's face it; with just about any series, the fan-art earns much more attention than the fan-writing, and it's not hard to guess why. I don't think it's only a result of the TL;DR epidemic, though that is a problem; most people will agree that it's just simpler and more convenient to look at a picture rather than to rely on similes and metaphors on a page to develop a story in one's mind.
Then there's also the situation where some fanfiction are written in a rush, without consideration for punctuation and being faithful to the character. We all must have seen something that has made us cringe at some point. "LULZGOIMANZ." Those make the heads of fans spin, and in some cases, turn them away from the series entirely (which is always a shame).
But, I'm being obvious. Though I draw, sometimes I find I can express my thoughts much more clearly in writing, moreso when limitations in my skill prevent me from effectively executing my ideas. I'm one of those folks who take writing seriously and who look for validation, which is one of the hardest things to find. I've spoken to fellow writers who also aren't sure whether it's worse to receive no comments on a piece of work, or something brief, irrelevant or ignorant, like 'LOLHAWT.' I'll take anything I can get these days, but sometimes, you can't help but wonder if someone is reading deeply, and if you have reached out to them and sparked something in some small way. That's worth everything to me, personally - because after a while, writing for myself isn't enough.
" This sets the mood for what I mean to say/do. I'm considering to make a club for the posting and discussion of Lupin fanfiction - not crackfics, or the fanfics authors don't bother to proofread (I'm sure we've read some with wonky punctuation and unexplained smut,) but the ones that are in-character, and aren't all about shipping. When an author's enthusiasm for a fandom lies only or mainly with its pairings (I'm not saying everyone thinks this way, mind you,) I feel it's as if they're just viewing the characters as pretty little dolls to play with and show off on a shelf and they're missing the bigger picture.
Anyway, I love art, and doodling's great fun, but I don't only want to be seen for that. As mentioned before, I seek validation, and I think any person who has a serious passion for writing aches for meaningful comments that reflect that a person at least read what you wrote on a level deeper than 'Cool'. Worse is when someone reads what you write and demonstrates a lack of basic comprehension by questioning something in the plot that's very straightforward.
I'm not asking you to hurry off and find my work right now, commenting just because you feel awkwardly obligated to do so. That would be missing the point, and besides, I honestly hate a lot of my old work here. I am working on tweaking my style. It's an ongoing journey.

I won't lie... making this club would, first of all, feed my need for these meaningful comments. I know I've taken a hard road with Goemon-centric fanfiction, and above all, depicting him as heterosexual. Seriously, before you get on my case if you're planning to do so, you have to admit that yaoifics involving the very same character do snag more attention. I have nothing against people liking what they like, but I can't help but hope that someone might one day turn to something I've done with the same interest. Not only my lovely, supporting friends with their 'friendly' bias.

I understand, of course, that my writing, for different reasons, might not float someone's boat.
Someone, without knowing it was me who they were talking to, said they disliked Goefics that are introspective and have 'big words', and I knew with complete certainty that they were referring to my work, more so as we frequent the same fanfiction site. I wasn't offended. I just laughed, but a little sadly, because it tells me that I've failed somehow in trying to reach out to people. I know I can't please anyone, but having put out fanfiction on that particular site and had a good number of recent ones go without a single review, I can't help but doubt myself and my ability to write effectively. (No, I'm not secretly hoping for people to contradict me right here - it's truly what I feel.)
I'm not looking for a pat on the head. I'd just like to know sometimes if things are as thought-provoking for them as it is for me, and I'm sure I'm not alone in this. It's just pathetic that I have to make my own place where I will feel things might work out for me, and where I can be among like-minded people in this who share and talk. Should I be getting this worked up about fanfiction? Probably not, I guess... but there's lingering resentment from places I've roleplayed at, where Goemon was just a name on the list to be filled. If you're a long-term, serious roleplayer yourself, you know that it hurts when you pour your thoughts and feelings into posts, and people aren't reading them. My very last post went overlooked to where I actually had to point out the fact that Goemon got into an accident, and that as a result, I gave up my character. Some only tend to pay attention to me when I'm angry, I've noticed, because I'm otherwise a nice little pushover, but even then...
Turns out that after almost a year of writing there, Goemon was still regarded as a miso soup-eating, proverb-spouting piece of cardboard. Even the satirical fic I wrote about Goemon being nothing more than a miso-soup eating, proverb-spouting piece of cardboard went overlooked. Maybe I was too subtle? In any case, that was a pretty big blow. It just felt like a big waste of time, but it's my own fault that I kept trying. Heck, not reading posts from scenes their characters weren't involved in? If you're only interested in your own characters in a roleplay, why not write a fanfiction? That should have been a BIG warning sign, but I was way too optimistic that things would work out. I don't doubt that there was desperation in me to find my niche in that place.
I'm still sore over it, more so because I haven't found any Lupin III roleplaying place that's just right yet, and I've been to a couple of places since. All well. I just hope that I don't lose my interest in the fandom before I've found a great bunch of people who know where I'm coming from.
Yeah. I'm both sorry for this huge block of text (I'd KILL you if, after all this, you wrote TL;DR) and not. I do repress a lot of feelings, and it is liberating to get this out there. Sure, roleplaying and fanfiction are not as important as matters in real life, BUT, if I can begin to express my feelings with these, maybe I can teach myself to uncork other feelings, too, before I drive myself nuts.
So yes. Am I going to quit roleplaying as Goemon and writing fanfiction because of this...? Hell no. In spite of everything, I still have hope.
Small, irrelevant edit, that doesn't deserve its own journal: I've read a silly thing about Goemon from that TVTropes site - apparently, someone or a group of people wrote somewhere that there has to be SOME reason that he is usually in his fundoshi for underwater scenes, suggesting that his choice of wear is generally viewed as an entirely fanservicey thing. Well, of COURSE there's a reason. Fundoshi do actually double as underwear AND swimwear. He's also not always in a fundoshi. Heck, I'm tempted to watch all the red jacket episodes I have, just to point out the times when he's in a diving suit. Not as many, of course, but it happened. Yeah, I know I'm crazy, no need to rub it in.
[link] It's listed here.
Anyone know how to edit/discuss a particular 'fact' listed on TVTropes? I have no idea how that site works. XD Leave it to me to feel compelled to correct something small on a site at four in the morning. I must right this wrong and triumph over ev- - er, no.